thinking big: feminism, media, and pop culture

Dance Moms: Labor, Power, and Girlhood

In Uncategorized on February 24, 2012 at 10:47 pm

Chelsea B.

Dance Moms premiered on Lifetime in the summer of 2011 and is currently in the midst of its second season. The premise of the show is based around Abby Lee Miller (center, in the gray velour above) who owns and runs a dance studio in Pittsburgh. Part of that studio is the Abby Lee Dance Company, which is a competition team comprised of the dancers Abby deems talented enough to earn an invitation to join. The show follows that team of dancers and their moms as they deal with Abby on what appears to be a daily basis about topics ranging from the age-appropriateness of the girls’ costumes to the girls’ often-tearful reactions to Abby’s harsh teaching techniques.

I don’t yet have a cohesive argument to make about the show as a whole, so instead I am going to list some of the qualities that I find compelling. Hopefully this will start a conversation that will enable a more sophisticated, collaborative analysis than I am currently able to create independently.

The Moms

Holly (Nia’s mom) is the only mom who has a paying job (some Googling suggests that she’s a principal at a private school). She is also the only mom of color on the show and the only one with a post-college education (she has a doctorate of education). There is frequent tension between Holly and Abby, as well as Holly and the other moms, in which Holly’s education and busy work schedule are used as barbs and reasons for her daughter Nia’s inability to “feel loved and supported” or dance as well as the other girls.

The other moms are portrayed as attending (and being expected to do so) every practice and sitting in a their designated loft area where they can watch their daughters dance while talking, sewing costumes, and, as is most often the case, fighting with one another. The show establishes the primary labor of these moms (with the exception of Holly) as negotiating between their daughters and Abby. Their job is to advocate for their daughters and to invest their time, money, and whatever power they can assert into achieving and maintaining their daughters’ seemingly ever-precarious position in the company. This advocacy happens in a number of ways:

  • The most direct way a mom usually advocates for her daughter is when she maxes out on seeing her daughter yelled at, neglected, or otherwise mistreated by Abby. Then the angered mom storms downstairs to interrupt the practice and have a fight with Abby or comfort her daughter.
  • Moms also advocate for their daughters by perpetuating a gift economy with Abby and the secondary choreographer. So far, season two has featured moms presenting Abby with gifts of perfume, jewelry, private massages set up at the studio, and a new park bench to sit in the front of the studio. It is made clear by the moms that these gifts are intended to purchase Abby’s special favor for their daughter, resulting in more attention and guidance from Abby and more featured roles or solos for their daughter in upcoming competitions. Abby accomodates this expectation verbally, (when she’s getting a massage gifted to her from Jill she says, “Put Kendall [Jill’s daughter] right in front!”) but seems to feel no obligation to follow through in action.
  • Moms also labor for their daughters in terms of the actual work of supporting a child in competition. The moms prepare and pack for travel on a near-weekly basis, travel alongside their daughters on buses and planes, set up elaborate dressing rooms in hotels, schools, and convention centers, take responsibility for the intricately detailed costumes that Abby usually requires, including hair and makeup, and sit through hours of competition. When the competition ends and awards are announced the moms then negotiate Abby’s inevitable criticisms by celebrating their daughters’ performances and talent, usually in front of the entire group.

The codes of how the show attributes power are complex and always shifting. Abby is always the loudest and clearly the most confident in her position of authority, but she also is frequently portrayed as overbearing, harsh, and unkind. Some episodes suggest that the moms who are smart, patient, and forbearing are the most powerful, but the very next week they will get trampled over. Alternately, the moms who mimic Abby’s behavior by screaming, fighting, and belittling one another are also usually portrayed as unsatisfied and regretful.

The most consistent source of power could be said to come from the girls themselves and the pyramid that Abby assigns them to; so, ultimately, it is Abby who has the most power, though sometimes the pyramid influences the girls’ behavior in unexpected ways, suggesting a less direct line of power than Abby would prefer.

The Girls

Every week, post-competition, Abby creates a pyramid on the mirrored wall of one of the studio rooms using tape and all of the girls’ headshots. (You can keep up with the girls’ positioning on the pyramid each week via the Dance Moms Wikipedia page.) She dramatically unveils one head shot at a time, explaining, more or less, how each girl “earned” their spot on the pyramid that week. The girls stand dutifully in a line during this process while the moms cluster off to the side, but are also expected to be in the room to hear about their daughters’ placement. The reasoning behind these pyramid assignments is completely arbitrary and not exclusively related to their performances. On a recent episode, Kendall was placed on the bottom row of the pyramid because of her mom, Jill’s, refusal to follow Abby’s rules about costuming. Jill loudly contested this, saying that her decision shouldn’t affect Kendall’s placement, but Abby ignored her and Kendall’s photo and position remained at the bottom. The one girl at the top of the pyramid is celebrated by her teammates and her mom is typically awarded as much camera time as she is while they both bask in the fleeting and rare warmth of Abby’s approval.

The show devotes a fair amount of time to following the girls during rehearsals as they learn new choreography, week after week. Rarely are the girls shown in their home or school environments, and never outside of the context of dance (i.e. we see Brooke in her bedroom during a recent episode, but it’s only to tape a conversation between her and her mom, Kelly, about whether or not Brooke will quit dance to try out for cheerleading). The physical strength and artistic talent of the girls is rarely remarked upon or featured in a way that would indicate it to be anything out of the ordinary. The moms and Abby throw around token phrases of admiration occasionally, but the majority of the girls’ dancing is taken for granted by the narrative constructed on the show.

The moms are clearly devoted to their daughters, as demonstrated visibly through their courting of and negotiations with Abby, but the girls themselves are their own biggest cheerleaders. After a round of competition, when the girls meet up in their dressing room, they are all squeals and hugs, celebrating each others’ performances. They are also sweetly supportive of one another during the grand pyramid reveal each week, usually hugging and congratulating the girl who earns the top position. As is normal considering their approximate age range of 7-10, the girls often display emotional fragility and cry during stressful rehearsals and cling to their mothers for support. However, less normal is the maturity and resilience they more often demonstrate in the face of extreme pressure (inflicted by Abby and their mothers) at competitions and during lectures at the studio from Abby.

Abby

As Abby said during a confessional on episode 7, “Bullets and Ballet,” of season 2: “I produce employable, working dancers, not competition kids.” The distinction Abby is drawing in this statement is one that separates the labor she performs and the work that her dancers perform by training to become “stars” rather than simply successful at filling the studio’s trophy case, though the two seem to go hand-in-hand. The separation comes in that Abby justifies her harsh training methods and zero-tolerance-for-tears policy by understanding these children as working professionals.

She demands complete authority in her studio, treating anything interpreted as insubordination or disrespect from the girls or the moms with temper tantrums of epic proportions. However, she is upfront and clear about this being the terms of engagement. Abby never pretends to position herself on the same level as either the moms or the girls; her mantle of power is never a burden to her. Abby will confidently assert her “over thirty years of experience,” track record of producing successful dancers, and talent as a choreographer and teacher to anyone who seems even slightly doubtful, forgetful, or uninformed.

Abby’s confidence and power as a businesswoman and educator is attractive, but is ultimately mitigated by her equal eagerness to humiliate, belittle, and insult her dancers and their mothers. This behavior might suggest some hairline cracks in her brash self-presentation, but Abby positions herself as powerful because she is willing to say and do whatever is necessary in order to maintain the authoritative structure she believes as integral to the successful functioning of the studio and company.

In short, Dance Moms has a lot going on. I’ve still got some questions:

What constitutes acceptable labor within this setting, and how are those terms created and communicated?

How do we understand the constant jockeying for power among the moms as a group and between the moms and Abby? How is power attributed, wielded, and revoked? Or, how does the dance studio function as a workplace and domestic sphere at once?

How are issues of race, class, gender, and sexuality addressed or elided?

What is considered to be nurturing for girls? How is childhood and, more importantly, girlhood constructed on the show? How does power inform the relationships among the girls as teammates and between the girls and Abby?

No, really. I’m asking. Tell me!

(Cross-posted from my HASTAC Scholars blog.)

Advertisements
  1. Chels, you bring up some really great points about the show and the way power is functioning … and you got me thinking about what kind of labor is valued, which seemingly is the domestic labor and labor of motherhood, rather than the kind of labor that Holly performs (ie schooling and having a full time job and being a mom). I think this is really interesting for a variety of reasons but one of them is that Abby’s labor is valued highly within the show and her labor is her career. So it seems like the show suggests that so long as you do not have kids, your labor is valuable outside the home, which seems like a throwback way of figuring labor and value instead of suggesting that both/all kinds are valuable (jobs, being a mom, etc). Almost too, it seems like from what you’ve said that the other moms being snarky about Holly’s job functions to suggest the importance of their jobs as dance moms and in that way they assert their labor as more valuable than Holly’s at a moment when a lot of women can and do work outside the home … Anyway, I really appreciated the way you framed the discussion as one about labor and power …

  2. Interesting post, Chelsea! Although I hate this show (for reasons I’ll discuss in a moment), I’m totally addicted to it, and I think you’re right to zero in on how critical the issue of labor is in this show.

    The dance world is vehemently fighting back against the notion of the ALDC being any kind of “real” representation of what the dynamics of a dance studio and competition team are like (see the “Positive Dance Moms (and Dads” group on Facebook, for example). I would have to agree with them — in my 20+ years of dancing and competing, I’ve run into a lot of crazy competition coaches and dance parents, but none quite as crazy as the characters in the show… and hopefully my competition team doesn’t think that I am anything like Abby! Nevertheless, your analysis of labor made me realize that as much as this show is not-so-real “reality” TV, the series does point to some interesting “real” problems in the world of dance, girlhood, and motherhood.

    For example, I think you’re absolutely right that this show privileges the idea of a mother’s labor as watching, advocating for, and supporting her daughter in dance. Hence, Holly is sometimes a sort of outsider when she misses a pyramid meeting, a rehearsal, or (heaven forbid) a competition weekend. Abby comes down hard on her, and so do some of the “new” moms, but even the support of her career from the moms that are her friends doesn’t outweigh all of the negative commentary that we hear about her “hurting” Nia by not being there.

    That being said, I think Melissa and Cathy would be interesting to consider in light of the labor issue. Melissa, of course, works at the front desk for Abby and does whatever Abby wants her to do, and the other moms assume that she does this job to get special favors for her two daughters. However, we don’t know for sure. It is possible that Melissa is in fact using the position to be in Abby’s good graces, but it could also be that she needs the job to get reduced tuition and help pay for her daughter’s expenses (which must be absolutely outrageous for this team… to give you a general idea, I’m taking 4 dances to a Portland competition and it will cost us $800 dollars in entry fees alone). Although there are certainly other issues going on that keep the other moms from being friends with Melissa, she seems to be an outsider too in that she manages to be there for the meetings and can watch her daughters’ rehearsals, but she has a different relationship to Abby than the other moms do.

    Cathy, of course, never fit in with the group (though she did make friends with Melissa, possibly because they were both outsiders) since she owns her own dance studio and the other moms could never figure out why Candy Apples wasn’t good enough for Vivi. Cathy was largely unsatisfied with her role in the ALDC because she only wanted to approach it from the perspective of a studio owner and teacher, not from the perspective of a mom. She considered herself an “equal” with Abby — and neither Abby nor any of the moms did! So here, I think it would be fair to say that (obnoxious as Cathy can be), she did not understand what kind of labor she was supposed to contribute to the team.

    I also want to point out two other things that might be of interest. One, in last week’s episode, we finally got a glimpse of why Christi has stayed at Abby’s studio even though she often feels as if she is torturing Chloe: it is an issue of Abby’s “contracts.” While I can’t remember Christi’s explanation word for word, it is something to the effect that Abby “owns” her daughter for the year and if they were to break the contract early, they would owe $100,000 within a week and Abby would negatively influence Chloe’s career wherever she went. This contract takes away from the power of both the mom and the dancer, but particularly the dancer. Although the girls’ success week-to-week is up to them (as Abby frequently reminds them), Abby still reinforces her role as the “producer” of these talented, professional “workers” by her strict and contractual control of their training and performances.

    Secondly, in light of how the episodes are actually edited, it is interesting to think about the “work” that the moms do in comparison to their daughters. During classes and rehearsals, the mothers are most often in the viewing room bickering (with nothing else to occupy their time), and we frequently see them going out together or having other moms over to their house. In contrast, we see mentally and physically exhausted girls (who, given their age and physical strength from dance training, have built up amazing stamina, so their exhaustion is telling of the rigors of Abby’s training). The exception might be competition weekends, when the moms have more work to do in terms of packing for travel and helping the girls to get ready backstage. Yet, on this past week’s episode, we also see the moms irritation at Abby’s request that they make costumes for the girls’ solos — reinforcing, at least to some extent, that they are not accustomed to this kind of “work.” As for these mothers’ lives outside of the dance studio, we are given the impression that everything is in a mess, and that their real calling is to be at the studio with the girls (a la the lyrics to the opening – “my world is with my girls, living on the dance floor”).

    Sorry for the long comments… so many things to think about with respect to this show!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: