thinking big: feminism, media, and pop culture

Rebound: Being Unique on “Glee”

In gender, girl culture, Glee on April 25, 2012 at 5:11 pm

Phoebe B.

Lena Dunham’s hotly anticipated Girls is still the topic of the week, with bad and good reviews in every major and minor news outlet. In all the hubbub, I worry that we might have missed what was (for me at least) the most exciting moment of television in some time. Last week, Glee addressed being gender non-conforming through high school student and Vocal Adrenaline member Wade/Unique. Wade feels more at home when expressing his gender as feminine and the amazing Unique is definitely not the kind of girl who gets included in Girls.

Unique is played by Alex Newell, from last year’s Glee Project. Alex regularly performed in drag during the show. For example, he once wowed Ryan Murphy by singing “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going” from Dreamgirls as Effie White, which may or may not have brought me to tears (I love that song!). He is truly talented and I loved him on the Glee Project (and on Glee for that matter). Sadly, he didn’t win the Glee Project, but I am grateful that Ryan Murphy saw his talent and cast him anyway—and I would LOVE to see more of him.

So here’s what happened on Glee last week: Wade asked Kurt and Mercedes whether he should perform as Unique in a Vocal Adrenaline show. The duo dissuades him from doing so, then persuades him (per Sue’s evil-ish influence), and then attempts to dissuade him again. The final dissuading, however, is unsuccessful, and Wade goes on to perform as Unique and wow the crowd. She sings, following the Disco themed episode, “Put on My Boogie Shoes.”

While Kurt and Mercedes briefly address the dangers inherent to Wade performing as Unique in public in Ohio, the conversation is quite brief. And, Unique’s apparent and overwhelming reception is perhaps unrealistic (but is also great). Indeed, Sue’s encouragement is based on her assumption that a performance by Unique will tank Vocal Adrenaline, hence her encouragement, but instead Unique wins the day. It is Glee after all, and this utopic response fits in well with the week’s lesson: that being yourself and having a dream will pay off.

For me, the most interesting part was the final moment before Unique took the stage, as Kurt and Mercedes try one last time to persuade Wade to perform as himself. However, Wade resists Kurt and Mercedes’ push for him to perform as a boy and with his resistance he pushes back on normative and prescriptive notions of gender. In this exchange, Glee suggests, I think, that Wade’s identity as a boy is a daily performance built and maintained to protect Unique from harm. Kurt seems confused and uncomfortable, for he, as Wade notes, has never felt discomfort or un-at home in his own body. Unique is not a performance of drag, as Kurt and Mercedes mistakenly believe. For Unique, to perform as herself is home.

While the episode and perhaps even the character is not perfect, Unique is one of the first positive representation (that I remember) of a gender non-conforming person (and teen) on network television, save perhaps for Isis, who is openly transgender, on last season’s America’s Next Top Model All Stars.

Isis from ANTM

Glee’s position on network TV, which is a historically conservative institution and significantly more widely available than say HBO, for example, makes a representation of a character like Unique rather significant. I think it is important to make girls like Unique visible on television and in our culture more generally, and to celebrate them.

There is definitely more to say here–about race, gender, and sexuality–and I would love to hear what you GLG folks and Glee fans are thinking!

  1. Thanks so much for this! I remember you mentioning that there would be a post on Unique soon, so I’ve been eagerly awaiting it. Also eagerly awaiting Alex’s appearance: I watched THE GLEE PROJECT, and found his character description to be the most compelling. I feel like I spent the whole last half of that season rooting for Alex based on criticism from the show fan boards, which ranged from dislike for his “diva” behavior (which come on, we’re talking theater kids, right?) to straight-up homophobia. I appreciate how you mention Wade’s pushback to Mercedes and Kurt. It was interesting to have a queer character that challenged Kurt’s near-hegemony on nonnormative gender and sexuality in the show. Unique would be such a great regular on the show. For me, his storyline was really the star of that episode, especially compared to the other TGP finalists: I can barely recall what they’ve contributed all season. Again, thanks.

    • Thanks JJ!! I definitely agree about Alex … I was such a fan of him (and Hannah) on the Glee Project and was sad that neither of them won and was actually super surprised by who won. And on Glee this season, I have been unimpressed by their appearances (I think it was Damien and Samuel who won?) save for Alex’s. I too thought his storyline was the most interesting and compelling. And, I am intrigued by Glee’s recent episodes (like the bullying one) that are overtly political …

  2. Loved Wade/Unique, it’s the only new character that’s interesting. Damian and the other Glee Project winner (what’s his name?) weren’t as near as good as Alex was. Btw, they misteriously wroted off Damian and that girl Summer from this episode, they weren’t with the cast on the dancing scenes.

  3. Not sure how you’re defining positive, but Ugly Betty had Alexis, a trans woman played by cis woman Rebecca Romijn and Dirty Sexy Money had Carmelita, a trans woman played by trans woman Candis Cayne. Both aired on ABC.

    • Thanks for reminding me of Alexis and Carmelita, Christina! I didn’t watch Dirty, Sexy, Money and only really watched early seasons of Ugly Betty … So I would love to know what you thought of those characters?

  4. […] and to our equally awesome readers. You are the smize in our eyes, the Knope in our hope, the Unique wonder that makes us feel glee. Basically, you’re the best. Without you, we’re just a […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: